Is It Acceptable To Transplant Hair Into Areas of The Scalp That Are Only Thinning?

Robert,

Thank you for taking the time to write! I am not sure I can speak for the majority of hair transplant surgeons, but through my training and experience with many of the top surgeons out there, the short answer to your question is; it is a judgement call.

The chief concern, as you identified, is whether you will do more harm to the existing hair, than good! If the existing hair is close to complete loss, I believe many surgeons would choose to help that patient by restoring a conservative area of hair/hairline.

If the hair in the area seems to be salvageable, some surgeons would feel more comfortable trying medical therapy alone for 6-12 months, while others would simply exercise caution during the transplant. Too many grafts at once with the latter approach can exacerbate shock loss, especially if the patient has fine or miniaturized hair to begin with.

If you believe you are in this latter category, it is always best to go with the hair surgeon who levels with you about the risk of shock loss; you will be replacing the hair with permanent hair, so you will have a net benefit, but the risk of significant shedding with more limited re-growth does exist.

All of the above refers to hair on the top of the scalp no matter where it is thinning. I’d like to mention, however, that the crown is a unique area with its own set of problems. If the only thinning area you want to fill in is the crown, a patient should seriously consider going on Propecia or deferring surgery entirely until it is clear that the frontal area will not need the grafts more than the back!

The reason is that the grafts are in limited supply, and you want to be able to place them in the most cosmetically beneficial area possible – get the most bang for your grafts! – so to speak. The most cosmetically beneficial area is almost always the front, since it is a natural balding pattern to have some crown loss but still have your face framed conservatively. So, whether there is some hair remaining in the crown area or not, many hair physicians would think twice about treating this area aggressively.

I hope that answers your question! Remember that the best surgeons will not treat any area that still has hair in it without having a long discussion with the patient about expectations and alternative medical treatments first. Good luck and I wish you good hair!